Journal article
Publication: Participatory Appraisal of the impact of fisheries policy and governance reform: The Case of the Yawri Bay marine Protected area along the Coast of Sierra Leone
The potential of the Fisheries of Sierra Leone to make significant contributions to societal wellbeing has been firmly acknowledged. Nevertheless, the sector has failed to play its optimum possible role in the country’s economic development. Having examined the opportunities the sector have to offer and the challenges holding it back from achieving developmental goals, the Government of Sierra Leone recently commissioned targeted projects to seize sectoral opportunities and address challenges. Chief among these projects are the West African Regional Fisheries Programme in Sierra Leone (WARFP-SL) and West African Pilot Project in Sierra Leone (WAPP-SL). WARFP-SL focused on Resource Governance, Reduction of Illegal Fishing and Official Quality Control & Value Addition. WAPP-SL on the other hand, realises that a precondition for successful fisheries development is the establishment and operationalisation of appropriate fisheries policy/legal frameworks, and the design/implementation of fisheries management plans. The aforesaid resource stewardship interventions require policy and governance reforms which could generate losers and or winners. Understanding the impact on those that fail to benefit from such reforms particularly from the lens of those charged with implementation in the field; is decisive for compliance during and after the transition to reformed fisheries management systems. For example, change management is crucial for achieving resource-wealth benefits without sacrificing other benefits. This paper gauges the likely impacts of instituted reforms on practitioners (focusing on CMA executives in the clustered fisheries communities) in the Yawri Bay Marine Protected Areas - one of the most productive, yet vulnerable fisheries ecosystems along the coast of Sierra Leone. Analysis evaluated the philosophy underpinning the reforms sought by the projects which formed the basis for identifying strategies as to how wealth realised from fisheries as a result of reforms can be redistributed to facilitate livelihood adjustment for would-be losers. Juxtaposing reform activities/ counter activities with the possible environmental / socio-economic impacts and the emanating winners/ losers; enabled the discernment and isolation of the mitigating actions recommended. Participatory impact appraisal indicated a desirable environmental impact score of 72% and no adverse environmental impact was recorded. However, whilst a desirable socio-economic impacts score of 66% for possible winners was observed; an even higher adverse socio-economic impact score of 68% was recorded for would-be losers. This is indicative of hard trade-offs between environmental gains and the accompanying difficult socioeconomic effects on the wellbeing of vulnerable stakeholders.
